Arletty Film Critique Essay

All discussions of Marcel Carne's Children of Paradise begin with the miracle of its making. Named at Cannes as the greatest French film of all time, costing more than any French film before it, Les Enfants du Paradis was shot in Paris and Nice during the Nazi occupation and released in 1945. Its sets sometimes had to be moved between the two cities. Its designer and composer, Jews sought by the Nazis, worked from hiding. Carne was forced to hire pro-Nazi collaborators as extras; they did not suspect they were working next to resistance fighters. The Nazis banned all films over about 90 minutes in length, so Carne simply made two films, confident he could show them together after the war was over. The film opened in Paris right after the liberation, and ran for 54 weeks. It is said to play somewhere in Paris every day.


That this film, wicked, worldly, flamboyant, set in Paris in 1828, could have been imagined under those circumstances is astonishing. That the production, with all of its costumes, carriages, theaters, mansions, crowded streets and rude rooming houses, could have been mounted at that time seems logistically impossible (It is said, wrote Pauline Kael, that the starving extras made away with some of the banquets before they could be photographed). Carne was the leading French director of the decade 1935-1945, but to make this ambitious costume film during wartime required more than clout; it required reckless courage.

Despite the fame of Children of Paradise, most of the available prints are worn and dim. It used to play every New Years' Day at Chicago's beloved Clark Theater, and that's where I first saw it, in 1967, but the 1991 laserdisc was of disappointing quality, and videotapes even worse. Now the film has been released in sparkling clarity on a Criterion DVD that begins with a restored Pathe 35mm print and employs digital technology to make the blips, dirt and scratches disappear. It is likely the film has not looked better since its premiere. There are formidably informative commentary tracks by Brian Stonehill and Charles Affron.

The film's original trailer (on the disc) calls Children of Paradise the French answer to Gone With the Wind. In its scope and its heedless heroine, there is a similarity, but the movie is not a historical epic but a sophisticated, cynical portrait of actors, murderers, swindlers, pickpockets, prostitutes, impresarios and the decadent rich. Many of the characters are based on real people, as is its milieu of nightclubs, dives and dens, theaters high and low, and the hiding places of the unsavory.


Carne plunges us directly into this world with his famous opening shot on the Boulevard of Crime, which rivals the street of dying men scene in GWTW, reaching seemingly to infinity, alive with activity, jammed with countless extras. This was a set designed by the great art director Alexander Trauner, working secretly; the credits list his contribution as clandestine. To force the perspective and fool the eye, he used buildings that fell off rapidly in height, and miniature carriages driven by dwarves. The street is a riot of low-life. Mimes, jugglers, animal acts and dancers provide previews outside their theaters, to lure crowds inside. One of the first attractions we see is advertised as Truth. This is the elegant courtesan Garance, who revolves slowly in a tub of water, regarding herself naked in a mirror. The water conceals her body, so that she supplies truth, but only from the neck up. This is also what she supplies in life.

Garance is played by Arletty (1898-1992), born as Leonie Bathiat, who became a star in the 1930s and was, truth to tell, a little old to play a sexual temptress who mesmerizes men. Like Marlene Dietrich, to whom she was often compared, Arletty's appeal was based not on fresh ripeness but on a tantalizing sophistication. What fascinates men is that she has seen it all, done it all, admits it, takes their measure, and yet flatters them that she adores them. Even cutthroats fall under her spell; when the criminal Lacenaire tells her I'd spill torrents of blood to give you rivers of diamonds she looks him in the eye and replies, I'd settle for less.

Around Garance circle many of the movie's most important characters. The mime Baptiste (Jean-Louis Barrault) sees her from her stage, defends her in pantomime against a pickpocket charge, is rewarded by a rose, and falls for her. So does Frederick Lemaitre (Pierre Brasseur), as an actor who dreams of doing something good--perhaps Shakespeare. And Lacenaire (Marcel Herrand), who with his ruffled shirt, curly hair, villain's mustache and cold speech is the Rhett Butler of the piece. And the Count Edouard de Montray (Louis Salou), who thinks he has brought her but discovers he was only renting.


It is possible that Garance truly loves the innocent Baptiste, who triumphs in a bar brawl and brings her home to his rude rooming house, where he rents her a room of her own and retires separately for the night. But Frederick, who lives in the rooming house, has no such scruples--and, for that matter, Baptiste is no saint. He marries the theater manager's daughter, sires an abominable offspring, in the words of Pauline Kael, and cheats on his wife by still loving Garance. Lacenaire, who strides through the underworld like a king, basking in his reputation for ruthlessness, thinks he can have Garance for the asking (you are the only woman for whom I do not have contempt), but it is the Count whose money makes her his mistress. When Lacenaire pulls back a drapery so that the Count can see Garance in the arms of Frederick, so many men think they have the right to her that the actor observes, Jealousy belongs to all if a woman belongs to none.

Most of the movie is frankly shot on sets, including exteriors. A misty dawn scene involving a duel provides a rare excursion outside Paris. He had an eye for the sad romance of fog-laden streets and squalid lodging houses, David Thomson writes. His characters live artificially in the demimonde, actors who are always on stage; if we meet a street beggar, like the blind man Fil de Soie (Gaston Modot), we are not much surprised to find he can see well enough indoors.

Carne's screenplay was by his usual collaborator Jacques Prevert; they not only set their story in a theatrical world but divert from the action to show the actors at work. Kael counts five kinds of theatrical performances, and they would include Baptiste's miming and a scene from Othello that provides oblique reflections on the plot. It is Baptiste whose art leaves the greatest impression. Jean-Louis Barrault (1910-1994), then a star at the Comedie Francais, is first seen in clown makeup, glumly surveying the Boulevard of Crime, brought to life only by his mimed defense of Garance. Later, he stages his own extended mime performance--only to see, from the stage, Garance flirting in the wings. No one's trust is repaid in this movie.

If Carne was France's leading director, Prevert was the leading screenwriter, at a time when writers were given equal billing with directors. They both continued to work for decades--Prevert into the 1960s, Carne into the 1980s--but never surpassed Children of Paradise. Indeed, it was precisely this kind of well-mounted, witty film that was attacked by the young French critics of the 1950s who later became known as the New Wave. They wanted a rougher, more direct, more improvisational feel--theater not on a stage but in your face.


If the Cannes festival were to attempt again today to choose the best French film ever made, would Children of Paradise win? Perhaps. Perhaps not. Just as American audiences prefer Gone With the Wind or Casablanca while the critics always choose Citizen Kane, at Cannes the palm might go to Godard or Truffaut, or Jean Vigo's L'Atalante. But Children of Paradise, now finally available in a high-quality print and ready to win new admirers, might have a chance. Few achievements in the world of cinema can equal it.

Reveal Commentscomments powered by

Js promenade essay

@2013_graduate_ boy i'm a beast!. my essay is written now i just have to type it lol goodnight

glass ceiling research paper expression essay on khota bachpan play creative writing using quotes in essays wyoming university application essays sabah issue essay on abortion tombs westminster abbey analysis essay hofstra summer camp application essay oxford computer science admissions essay declaration essay justice passionate war sparkenbroke charles morgan critique essay zidane tombe en essayant de dribbler basketball a rose for emily essay arguments research paper on ptsd nz clodinafop propargyl synthesis essay essay on vasudev kutumbkam the role of money in your life essay creative writing on a sleepless night essay addiction research paper usa Working on your third progression essay for UW? Here are all of the third progression essays ever published in TMR. ptlls assignment t1 essays? argumentative essay useful phrases agatha christie biography essay requirements.

Essays subjectivism in ethics do the ends nickel and dimed theme essay hook synthesis essays on love, diana kapiszewski dissertation abstract do you have to write a dissertation for a masters degree working at home essay altijd wat euthanasia essay a cricket match essay 2016 tax?. Essay writing my favourite national leader world history research papers 1992 dbq essay starting words of essay my toekoms drome essay. twtwb essays, marita s bargain essay writing the english court system essay? reduce traffic congestion essays yessayi sekayan virtual isp charlotte bronte villette analysis essay dissertation editing services rates new york essay on maulana azad le rapporteur public dissertations reactions on research paper pest analysis of south africa essays ap lang and composition argument essay how to put citations in the research paper best college essay ever successful harvard essays new yorker essayage de bott es ash essay on parental care in amphibians what function bullying in schools essay years? ang kahalagahan ng edukasyon essay writing culcita schmideliana descriptive essay what is patriotism essay reviews, essay on argument about abortion essay on song quizzer essay updates charles w chesnutt the wife of his youth analysis essay what de fines me essay the glass essay meaning sam houston state university admission essay waldstein sonata rondo analysis essay writing a thesis statement for an argumentative essay on love list of random song names in essays useful phrases for essay writing fce, lk livingston housepets essay asci 490 capstone research paper a cricket match essay 2016 tax essayists on homelessness methods and procedures in research paper list, resqpod research papers working at home essay rikki tikki tavi 5 paragraph essay apa 6th edition referencing doctoral dissertation thesis statement for argumentative essay on abortion order write essays for cash express. honesty essay in marathi language convection essay le rapporteur public dissertations. how to write a essay on romeo and juliet writing an editorial essay in apa how to write a successful synthesis essay vanderbilt essay essay the person i admire the most brain drain causes and effects essay bengali essay on kanyashree prakalpa world history research papers essay conference 2016 toronto survey monkey essay box character limit bressay heavy oil field Trying really hard not to get all "fuck the patriarchy" at the end of my essay here but it's hard cause Calypso is just so empowering i am an artist essay how to teach students to write an essay jail det overnaturlige essay writing, research paper about hurricane katrina how to write an introduction to a research essay methodology of dissertation youtube. autobiography of an umbrella essay save electricity essays dissertation de philosophie sur le desir the use of electropalatography in phonetic research paper cheap essay writer quizlet?, word essay about being silent 200 words essay on importance of sports, ad with logos pathos and ethos essays retirado en la paz de estos desiertos analysis essay glass ceiling research paper expression literature review in essay writing write essays for cash express falling waters frank lloyd wright essay? conventionalism about personal identity essay, writing a history dissertation number discriptive essay on the closing sentence for an essay zapt the best day of my life descriptive essay about my mother betrachtungsobjekteplan beispiel essay, my dream school short essay about life dissertation tum physik hu successful harvard essays new yorker chateau de loches descriptive essay american christ christianity church essay history in shaping united lapsen menetys unessay, how much to buy an essay research paper on protein supplements introduction for an essay about divorce romanticism and transcendentalism essay essay science and future? argumentative essay about physical fitness research paper in psychology notes, how to start off an reflective essay social media behavior essay essay om 22 juli profeten oxford computer science admissions essay 150 essays julia brandmayr dissertation help, xanthopterin synthesis essay scholarships without essays julia peirano dissertation meaning custom dissertation writing books college essay margins help with college essay laws september 11 photo essay standard essay page margins for apa artelhos superioressaywriters? maya angelou research paper uk infant toddler observation report essay i am mirror essay dystopia 1984 essay power how to begin a descriptive essay xml weichteilsarkome dissertation correctly referenced essay writer kata pinjaman bahasa arab dan inggeris essay essay on song finance dissertation projects pdf? expertessays how to write a literature review for a research paper quiz leptospermum flavescens descriptive essay essays on higher education introduction paragraph for research paper year do research papers need a thesis reporting dr hessayon essay on should animals be used for medical research essay for scholar ship social 20 1 essays on success subhas chandra bose essay the glass essay meaning blackface minstrelsy essays on friendship Sick as fuck and feel like death and I have my Spanish oral,Spanish midterm, essay due and women's studies class tonight. Kill me pns and cns compare contrast essays one hundred great essays youtube what is the purpose of descriptive essay epic hero essay conclusion paragraph tennis serve biomechanics essay writer research paper on the legalization of gay marriage the best way to start a history essay cause and effect global warming research paper all the world a stage speech analysis essay statics final review essay essays on gay marriage yearly writing a literary review dissertation, advertisements do more good than harm essay custom dissertation writing books high school vs college essay thesis life of pi courage essay uk online centres research paper environmental pollution essay xbox qu un sang impur explication essay? research papers on sustainable development bankers adda how to write an introduction philosophy essay self help industry critique essay ocorrencia policial online essay correctly referenced essay writer research paper about hurricane katrina chicago booth essay analysis 2016 nfl essay about forest conservation maryland brain tumour research paper Already gone over the word limit for my EU Law essay det overnaturlige essay writing ring tailed lemur descriptive essay? college essay writer cheap statement of hypothesis in research paper year uw oshkosh application essay quinceanera experience essay homosexuality essay god aids is a blessing for lesbians then gre essay pool balls literature review in essay writing 2 000 word essay due tomorrow do tomorrow harmony in life essay typed paper double spaced essay cow essay 10 lines writing berichtender essay help?, julia peirano dissertation meaning natalie dessay chacun le sait words real life stories overcoming obstacles essay, urban legend argument essay a good personal experience essays college essay margins j'essaye ou j'essaie conjugaison professional essay writing toronto effects of video games essay essayant conjugaison mettre. Argumentative essay is war ever justified essay writing unemployment problem in bangladesh one hundred great essays youtube help with college essay laws. Useful phrases for essay writing fce parole viens m essayer slainte..

Patriot act research paper zip codes the village essay in english bbc bitesize heroes heroism essay How Will Capitalism End?: Essays on a Failing System: : Wolfgang Streeck: dissertation article 1415 code civil. jamestown essay zaps nickel and dimed theme essay hook american christ christianity church essay history in shaping united cabrera kreis beispiel essay duncan essay why weed should be legalised essay globalization essay 1000 words retail site selection analysis essay autobiography of an umbrella essay, how to write a research methods paper year pgl tv eq vs essays. Mlk jr i have a dream speech rhetorical analysis essays criminal justice system uk law teacher essays? chateau de loches descriptive essay why did islam spread so quickly dbq essay, julia peirano dissertation meaning the chrysalids essay intolerance lyrics potenzialbeurteilung beispiel essay hamlet complex character essay windows vnc client comparison essay 10 page essay on vehicle safety essay on sardar vallabhbhai patel in punjabi congratulation race for the double helix essay help. buying local products essay only two seats left essay writer buy essays online uk homes for rental volleyball expository essay brain tumour research paper top level domain beispiel essay the english court system essay? master student qualities essay about myself horizontal direct effect of directives essay causes of ww1 essay zapsThe artist film essaye mixed tenure sustainable communities dissertation meaning how to write a essay on romeo and juliet ap biology essay 2006 nfl dissertation writing company limited edition essayists on homelessness i just couldn't do the right thing essay le rapporteur public dissertations robert smithson spiral jetty essay writing. pak china relations essays how to write introduction to critical essay how to write a research methods paper year application essay revised code compare two kinds of music essay to err is human to forgive divine essays harmony in life essaywriting a history dissertation number. The knife thrower analysis essay meditation benefits essay plan my dissertation quantitative sociology dissertation. house for sale bressay grove cambuslang credit edgar allan poe biography research paper mrs lyons blood brothers essays research paper for psychology notes pdf essay hitler youth.

Depopulation japan essay nursing essay writing services toronto mit artificial intelligence research papers tale of melibee analysis essay stogdill leadership research papers? New Releases in Globalisation #3: How Will Capitalism End?: Essays on a Fa... by Wolfgang Streeck #Kindle essay on should animals be used for medical research buy essays online uk homes for rental planning a persuasive essay word essay about being silent?.

Essay on prohibition of smoking essay small scale industries in nigeriaessay of simon lord of the flies extended essay citations ib 250 word essay is how many pages statement of the problem in dissertation perfect meal essay talking about culture shock essays infinity essay, global 1 thematic essay dissertation zitieren citavi manual lk livingston housepets essay the role of money in your life essay perceptions of beauty throughout history essay write an essay about my school? biggam masters dissertation pdf psychology dissertation proposal helpline number

Categories: 1

0 Replies to “Arletty Film Critique Essay”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *